10% Off Your First Order! Promo Code FIRST10
Horror & Mystery Fall Savings!

Limited Time: Spend More, Save More

Spend $25, Get 15% Off • Spend $50, Get 25% Off • Spend $75, Get 35% Off

Applied automatically at checkout. Some product exclusions may apply. Now through November 17th 12:00pm ET.

All Horror & Supernatural

All Horror & Supernatural

3065 Items

Paranormal & Monsters

Paranormal & Monsters

1838 Items

Psychological Horror

Psychological Horror

87 Items

Zombies

Zombies

317 Items

All Mystery & Suspense

All Mystery & Suspense

2083 Items

Crime & Noir

Crime & Noir

1487 Items

Thrillers

Thrillers

331 Items

Mystery & Horror Fall Savings

Featured Products

3906 products

Witching Hour 1969 Series #69
Spend More Save More

Witching Hour 1969 Series #69

From $10.20
From $10.20
Witching Hour 1969 Series #18
Spend More Save More

Witching Hour 1969 Series #18

$13.94
$13.94
image-coming-soon
Spend More Save More

Witchfinder: The Reign of Darkness #2

$6.00
$6.00
image-coming-soon
Spend More Save More

Witchfinder: The Reign of Darkness #1

$6.00
$6.00
Witchfinder: The Mysteries of Unland #1
Spend More Save More

Witchfinder: The Mysteries of Unland #1

$3.60
$3.60 $7.20
Witchfinder: The Gates of Heaven #4
Spend More Save More

Witchfinder: The Gates of Heaven #4

$3.81
$3.81
Witchfinder #2
Spend More Save More

Witchfinder #2

From $3.00
From $3.00
Witchfinder #1
Spend More Save More

Witchfinder #1

$1.43
$1.43 $2.85
Witch Doctor: Mal Practice #6
Spend More Save More

Witch Doctor: Mal Practice #6

$2.86
$2.86
Witchcraft: La Terreur #3
Spend More Save More

Witchcraft: La Terreur #3

From $1.00
From $1.00
Witchcraft: La Terreur #2
Spend More Save More

Witchcraft: La Terreur #2

From $2.86
From $2.86
Witchcraft 1994 Series #2
Spend More Save More

Witchcraft 1994 Series #2

$4.00
$4.00
Witchcraft 1994 Series #1
Spend More Save More

Witchcraft 1994 Series #1

From $2.67
From $2.67
Wisdom #6
Spend More Save More

Wisdom #6

$2.72
$2.72 $6.80
Wisdom #4
Spend More Save More

Wisdom #4

$2.24
$2.24 $5.60
Wisdom #2
Spend More Save More

Wisdom #2

From $2.24
From $2.24 $5.60
image-coming-soon
Spend More Save More

Winniebago Graveyard #4

$4.00
$4.00
image-coming-soon
Spend More Save More

Winniebago Graveyard #3

$4.00
$4.00
image-coming-soon
Spend More Save More

Winniebago Graveyard #2

$4.00
$4.00
image-coming-soon
Spend More Save More

Winnebago Graveyard #4

$6.00
$6.00
Who is Jake Ellis? #4
Spend More Save More

Who is Jake Ellis? #4

$2.24
$2.24 $5.60
Who is Jake Ellis? #3
Spend More Save More

Who is Jake Ellis? #3

$5.60
$5.60
White Suits #4
Spend More Save More

White Suits #4

$2.24
$2.24 $5.60
White Suits #3
Spend More Save More

White Suits #3

From $2.24
From $2.24 $5.60
White Like She #4
Spend More Save More

White Like She #4

$1.53
$1.53 $3.82
White Like She #2
Spend More Save More

White Like She #2

From $1.60
From $1.60 $4.00
Whispers #6
Spend More Save More

Whispers #6

$4.50
$4.50
Whispers #4
Spend More Save More

Whispers #4

$3.00
$3.00
Whispers #3
Spend More Save More

Whispers #3

$3.00
$3.00
Where Monsters Dwell 2015 Series #3
Spend More Save More

Where Monsters Dwell 2015 Series #3

$5.60
$5.60
Where Monsters Dwell 2015 Series #2
Spend More Save More

Where Monsters Dwell 2015 Series #2

$4.00
$4.00
Where Monsters Dwell 2015 Series #1
Spend More Save More

Where Monsters Dwell 2015 Series #1

$7.20
$7.20
Where Monsters Dwell 1970 Series #37
Spend More Save More

Where Monsters Dwell 1970 Series #37

$41.33
$41.33
Where Monsters Dwell 1970 Series #3
Spend More Save More

Where Monsters Dwell 1970 Series #3

$23.13
$23.13
Where Monsters Dwell 1970 Series #18
Spend More Save More

Where Monsters Dwell 1970 Series #18

$12.03
$12.03 $17.19
Where Monsters Dwell 1970 Series #13
Spend More Save More

Where Monsters Dwell 1970 Series #13

$7.03
$7.03
Where Creatures Roam #7
Spend More Save More

Where Creatures Roam #7

$9.17
$9.17
Where Creatures Roam #5
Spend More Save More

Where Creatures Roam #5

$9.17
$9.17
Where Creatures Roam #4
Spend More Save More

Where Creatures Roam #4

$15.20
$15.20
Where Creatures Roam #1
Spend More Save More

Where Creatures Roam #1

$21.42
$21.42
Whedon Three Way #1
Spend More Save More

Whedon Three Way #1

From $4.00
From $4.00
Werewolf By Night 2023 Series #1
Spend More Save More

Werewolf By Night 2023 Series #1

$10.80
$10.80
Werewolf By Night 2020 Series #4
Spend More Save More

Werewolf By Night 2020 Series #4

$6.00
$6.00
Werewolf By Night 2020 Series #3
Spend More Save More

Werewolf By Night 2020 Series #3

$7.20
$7.20
Werewolf By Night 2020 Series #2
Spend More Save More

Werewolf By Night 2020 Series #2

$7.20
$7.20
Werewolf By Night 1998 Series #2
Spend More Save More

Werewolf By Night 1998 Series #2

$2.86
$2.86
Werewolf By Night 1998 Series #1
Spend More Save More

Werewolf By Night 1998 Series #1

$3.00
$3.00
Werewolf By Night 1972 Series #40
Spend More Save More

Werewolf By Night 1972 Series #40

$34.28
$34.28
Werewolf By Night 1972 Series #36
Spend More Save More

Werewolf By Night 1972 Series #36

$110.00
$110.00
Werewolf By Night 1972 Series #33
Spend More Save More

Werewolf By Night 1972 Series #33

$8.84
$8.84